A feel good story with a meandering first and final act
I don't really know how a film like
Life of Pi
can be considered "unfilmable". Is it because the source material
contains content that most filmmakers would be too afraid to tackle or
is tthat they don't think it's possible to frame the film properly?
Since having seen
Life of Pi, I think any book or material from
any other medium can be filmed, but it must have the right director, the
right actor and the right crew who should carry the film and bring the appeal of the book it's based on to a certain audience. Best case scenario would be
The Lord of the Rings. Directed by Peter Jackson, who at the time had directed some B movie schlock had directed such an incredibly big and dense story of all three books under a large budget and all he did was to frame everything grand making audiences feel like they're in the
LOTR atmosphere.
Life of Pi has the right director from Ang Lee who directed films such as
Brokeback Mountain,
Lust Caution and
Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon, the right actor and the right team in special effects to actually deliver a story based on Yann martel's best selling adaptation that is emotionally contained as it establishes itself as a heavy handed, then becomes so visually engaging that it goes off the rails with a contradictory and saggy ending.